Christian Network

You are visitor: In Scotland the time is:
Christian Network


More From The Catholic Forum
Margaret O'Hearn:

ARROGANCE VS. HUMILITY

THE PARABLE OF THE PHARISEE AND THE TAX COLLECTOR

LUKE 18:9-14

“He spoke the following parable to some people who prided themselves on being virtuous and despised everyone else, “Two men went up to the Temple to pray, one a Pharisee, the other a tax collector. The Pharisee stood there and said this prayer to himself, ‘I thank you God, that I am not grasping, unjust, adulterous like the rest of mankind, and particularly that I am not like this tax collector here. I fast twice a week; I pay tithes on all I get’. The tax collector stood some distance away, not daring even to raise his eyes to heaven, but he beat his breast and said, ‘God be merciful to me a sinner.’ This man, I tell you, went home again at rights with God; the other did not. For everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, but the man who humbles himself will be exalted.”

Within this parable there is a very strong message that challenges the egocentricity of those who are unable to see their own faults, an egocentricity that is caused by false pride and arrogance.  How interesting it is, that the Pharisee did not say his prayer to God, but to himself. The Pharisee in this parable was entirely wrapped up in self. He believed that because he could do nothing wrong in the sight of God and therefore he was better than others. The tax collector, on the other hand, was seen as a man who was in league with the Romans by collecting their taxes, and as one who cheats the taxpayers. In the eyes of the Pharisee, the tax collector is someone who is despised, yet in the eyes of God, it is the tax collector who is justified through his humility in asking forgiveness and mercy because of his sins.

 

THE CHALLENGE OF THE PARABLE TODAY

 

What are the challenges within this parable that can be applied to daily life?  First of all there is the challenge of admitting “I could be wrong”.  When a person suffers from too much pride and is egocentric, that person is rarely able to admit the possibility of making a mistake or being wrong. The egocentric is one who is extremely self-centred to the point that he has created his own god called “self”.  The egocentric is like the Pharisee who considers himself to be perfect, whilst he looks down upon the tax collector. The egocentric might have the following characteristics:

·       Do wrong to others but refuse to acknowledge guilt;

·       Hate others and call it zeal;

·       Flatter others because of what they can do for us;

·       Lie to others and call it tact;

·       Pretend that it is prudent to be slow to defend God in public;

·       Selfishly push others aside and call it “getting our rights”;

·       Judge others and call it facing facts;

·       Refuse to give up the life of sin and call anyone who renounces sin an escapist;

·       Accumulate wealth and call it security;

·       Feel resentment towards the wealth of others and claim to be “defenders of the downtrodden’;

·       Deny the inviolable principles of law and claim to be “liberal”;

·       Begin sentences with “I” and condemn one’s neighbour for wanting to talk about himself;

·       Ruin family life by divorce by claiming to “want to live our own lives”;

·       Criticize others unjustly;

·       Judge virtues by the vices from which we abstain.

 

The Pharisee in the parable was self-righteous. He considered that all he had to do for salvation was to follow his own set of rules by keeping up his outward appearances; he considered himself to be superior to the tax collector because he paid his tithes and fasted twice a week. The behaviour that he exhibited was that of one who is full of self-pride. The tax collector, on the other hand, acknowledged his sins before God, and asking for His mercy. The tax collector was justified in the sight of God because of his humility, but the Pharisee was not.

The challenge therefore is to see how we rate against the characteristics of the egocentric. The question to be asked is:  Am I self-centred like the Pharisee?  Do I consider myself to be superior to others? Do I judge others according to my own standards? Do I push the rights of others aside with my boorish attitudes? Do I resent others who have more than myself? Do I refuse to acknowledge the sins in my life and therefore refuse to make necessary reforms to my behaviour? Do I act like the hypocrite – say one thing and do something else?

SELF-PRIDE COMES BEFORE THE FALL

“Well then sin entered the world through one man, and through sin, death, and thus death has spread through the whole human race because everyone has sinned. Sin existed in the world long before the Law was given.”  (Rom 5:12)

What was the sin the entered the world through one man?  The root of the sin of Adam was that of self-pride.

“Then the serpent said to the woman, “No! You will not die! God knows in fact that on the day that you eat it your eyes will be opened and you will be like gods, knowing good and evil. The woman saw that the tree was good to eat and pleasing to the eye, and it was desirable for the knowledge that it could give. She took some of its fruit and ate it.”  (Gen 3:4-6)

The lesson from the Fall of Adam of Eve is that it was the desire of Adam and Eve to be like God that caused them to give into the temptation of Satan. Through a desire for power, Eve took of the fruit and then gave some to her husband.  This desire to be like God, which is the cause of the sin of Adam and Eve, is at the very root of egocentric behaviour. It is the inherent characteristic that leads a person further and further into a life of selfishness, and away from God. 

When a person fails to exercise self-discipline, and the ego is allowed to take over, there is a decline into egotism through seven stages:

(1) Solicitation to do what is evil. Fulton Sheen writes:  “Evil is always willed because of the good elements, real or imagined, that accompany it. ”  [1]  Since our minds are aware of the fact that certain acts lead to sin, our task remains to resist the temptation or solicitation to sin.  However, to be a sin there must be consent of the will. Yet, like Adam and Eve, when we yield to sin, we try to blame other factors, such as “temperament” or call it a “human need”.  Just like the Pharisee in the parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector, “we tend to claim full credit for our virtues, while our faults we blame on the environment or on some provocation beyond human endurance. Yet, yet in more honest moments, we know that it is a superficial view that we take of ourselves, that we are not all we should like to be. It is then that we ask: “Why am I not better”?  [2] The first downward step comes when we deceive ourselves accepting a lying label that makes an evil thing seem good to us.

(2) Excitation of the passions; there is a feeling of pleasure, of wellbeing, or enchantment.  “No sooner is a solicitation to evil made welcome in the mind than there is a physical response – a stirring of passion or a thrill.” [3] However, at this stage there is no sin involved. One sins only through the consent of the will.

(3) Consent of the will:  The will always has, in itself and in cooperation with God’s help, the power to repel the evil that attracts, thus turning the experience into merit. In the case of the egotist, that consent is full and entire. “This happens when the will lets itself be drawn to taste wilfully of evil, despite the protests of conscience that recognize its true nature.” [4]

(4) Action: the evil passes from the will to the deed, from the desire to the execution, from the wish to the transaction, from the passion to its exploitation; [5]

(5) Habit: is reached when there is a repetition of the sinful acts, so that the rebellion becomes habitual. The evil action is now routine, a kind of second nature, and becomes an accepted part of the egotist’s life, that it almost stifles the summons of Divine Love in the conscience. At this stage the will has become so weak that it allows the body to seek to satisfy itself. The egotist has become bound up in his sin.

(6) Necessity:  the egotist becomes determined to indulge in his excesses over and over again. He may justify his weakness by denying that he has free will. The determination to evil can be likened to the hardening of the heart.

(7) Eternal death: the final stage of decline is that of eternal death of the mind and soul. At this point the egotist has declined into a life of alcoholism, drug addiction, prostitution, and mental disorder.

 

Despite the fact that the egotist rejects God in favour of self, God remains faithful, and he stands in the wings waiting for the opportunity for grace to penetrate the soul that has set itself upon the path of destruction. A troubled and remorseful conscience that has not yet killed the inner voice has always in it a token of life. There is hope for anyone, even the most wicked, so long as the wicked man still hates his evil: “The unforgivable sin is the denial of sin by the conscience.” [6]

CHANGING THE CENTRE OF ONE’S EXISTENCE

 

 

The egotist has at his/her centre, the ego, but the humble person has as his/her centre the Divine. The tax collector knew that he was a sinner and he dared not raise his eyes heavenward because he understood that he was responsible for his sins. The Pharisee, on the other hand, refused to acknowledge responsibility for any sin. By asking God’s forgiveness for his sins, the tax collector became justified in the sight of God, showing that despite his sinfulness, he was God-centred. On the other hand the Pharisee remained self-centred in his existence and was not justified in the sight of God.

Even though the egotist rejects God in favour of self, God is always looking for the trapdoor, which will allow the outpouring of grace, and a change of heart in the egotist. For just as a person will wait for a trapped bird to stop flapping around so that it can be released again into the open, God waits patiently for the egotist to stop flapping around and accept some self discipline. The words of Jesus say: “Come to me all you are weary and heavy burdened and I will give you rest.” (Matt 11:28).  These words are God’s invitation to those who are in need of self-discipline to come and surrender to the healing grace of God. There has to be a point when a person who is leading a life of sin reaches rock bottom, and through remorse begins to make a change in lifestyle.  The point at which this occurs is the point when remorse for the wicked lifestyle begins to set in. The addict, for example, suddenly realises that he/she cannot continue the same lifestyle and that permanent changes are necessary.  The wake up call, when it comes could be an arrest for possession of drugs or for theft, or it could be the slide into mental illness (not all mental illness has as its root cause, wrong-doing) and hospitalisation as a result of an attempt at suicide.  It is the point at which God’s gift of grace begins to penetrate into the soul and at last, the soul begins to acknowledge the existence of God.

How can the egotist change from having ego as the centre of its existence to having God as the centre of existence?  The road to change is not an easy one, for it requires placing oneself into the hands of God, and surrendering “self” to do His Will and not our own.   How can this be achieved?  A person, who is on the road to recovery, does not have to rely on his/her own resources, to achieve the essential change that will bring about a growth to maturity. There is help available for those who want to make permanent changes to their lives. There are self-help groups such as AA and GROW that teach people how to grow to maturity by surrendering themselves to the healing power of God. Just as the tax collector humbled himself by asking God for forgiveness, so the one recovering from mental breakdown humbles him/herself to God. It is through this surrender that the egotist begins to walk the path that leads to a reformed personality.

 

LEARNING HUMILITY

 

What does it take to humble oneself before the Lord?  How do we learn to let go of our self-pride and give ourselves totally to God, doing His Will alone?  The first step is the examination of conscience. It is the realisation that our behaviour is self-centred and taking responsibility for that self-centredness. The tax collector left the Temple justified because he had recognised that he was responsible for his sins. Acceptance of responsibility for one’s own actions is a necessary part of growing to maturity. Once the responsibility for one’s sins has been accepted, the next step is reconciling oneself to God, by repenting of those sins and where necessary making reparation for them.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



[1] Fulton Sheen “Lift Up Your Hearts” p 42

[2] op. cit.  p.42

[3] op. cit. p.43

 

[4] op cit. p 44

[5] ibid

[6] ibid p 19

Visit the Ichthus Bookshop
The Front Page